Review: The Red Sacrament

5 stars. I'm tempted to say this deserves 5 stars because it's an exquisite masterpiece; a debut as twinkly as it is bloody. But really I'm giving it that rating for the reading experience itself - for the escape and the immersion and the vivid ... depth to which I could swim in it. I've read a lot of reviews trying to sort out my thoughts with no luck, but I think I have a lot to say. Let's get into it.

The Red Sacrament beautifully presents for us the tale of Arnault, vampire in Paris. He and his brood (literal) have successfully run a theater for decades, perfecting their craft and preying on their nightly audience. And then they are visited by a witch, followed by sibling vampires, who shake Arnault out of his stasis. The second half of the story is set against the backdrop of war, Paris under siege, then violent revolution - to which Arnault bears witness, and is changed forever. 

Much has been written about the political sub- and above-texts here. Old vs new; rich vs poor; upper vs lower class; urban vs rural; monster vs human; poverty vs excess; and much more as the story explores capitalism, modernity, exploitation, societal transformation, and resistance to it. The “Marx meets Anne Rice” tagline is accurate. And I think I understand, somewhat, where Sara Hinkley was going, though I'm not smart enough to analyze it effectively. I just really enjoy the fact that most horror is political, and I would like to read more books - especially historical horror - that lean into this.

I can say that books like this will make you a better thinker, and maybe even a better writer. There's so, so much to chew on - or maybe I should say, drink in. The Red Sacrament will educate you, and throw new color on old legends. It will give you a new appreciation for language and art and imagery and history. It's well-researched, and it will inspire further research. It makes complex political and social placefinding so, so entertaining and fascinating. 

I am deeply interested in the narrative choices - especially the ending - and the stylistic ones. Purple prose isn't always my thing - and yeah, I rolled my eyes a couple of times. I snorted at it, I got tired of it. Oh, the drama! The melodrama! So many complaints about the slow plot and the flat characters and the repetition - I see what people mean, but those things didn't bother me so much. 

I guess this is/was my cup of tea, aesthetically and thematically. Right book, right time. I found it to be dreamy and unpredictable and certain moments took my breath away. I was captivated, especially toward the end. I've been tinkering with this review for like five days because frankly, I don't really want to let this book go. I can't wait to see what the author writes next. 

On my Christmas wish list for Santa this year: an illustrated version; a spin-off, or a sequel, or even a prequel; and an adaptation, on crunchy film with natural lighting and practical effects.

This "review" is very much all about me and my reaction to The Red Sacrament, and not a whole lot about The Red Sacrament itself. I suggest reading this excellent review for better commentary. And for more: Interview with the Vampire (the book by Anne Rice is the obvious mothertext here, but the movie is also a must-watch - TRS is no rip-off, it's a complement and a compliment); Penny Dreadful (tv show); The Queen of the Night (book by Alexander Chee - there is even a hot air balloon!); you know what would also be an interesting supplemental watch? Versailles (tv show), which gives a sparkly, wiggy, very inaccurate look at French royalty and excess. 

The Red Sacrament on: Amazon | Bookshop.org | Goodreads | StoryGraph

Review: The Woman in Black

5 stars. Excellent for the week before Halloween, but this would be even better-suited for December - you could even read it in one sitting on Christmas Eve. This was a re-read for me and I know the story quite well - but knowing what to expect didn't take away a single ounce of enjoyment. It's a bona fide horror classic: exceptional, exceptionally written and exceptionally scary. I was absolutely side-eyeing shadows and corners, especially toward the end. Keep a light on - it sneaks up on you.

Young Arthur Kipps is sent by his employer out of London into the countryside to visit Crythin Gifford and sort out the estate of recently-deceased client, Alice Drablow. While charmed by the expanse of the marshes and the rural market town, he is put off by the strange looks and dark comments made by the residents when he arrives. After an unsettling experience at the funeral and an even worse one at Eel Marsh House, Arthur begins to understand what haunts the town, and now him: the mysterious woman in black.

I read an article recently that posited Irish ghost stories often hinge on revenge; Scottish ghost stories explore reconciliation and sympathy; and English ghost stories tend to hinge on guilt. While I'm sure this theory will inspire an actual feast of contextual and contradictory arguments, you can't deny that there are plenty of examples to support. 

While I'm not sure The Woman in Black perfectly embodies the guilt referenced in the theory above (this is more of a combo guilt/revenge plot - female ghosts might be so scary to some because they represent a powerful return of the suppressed), I returned to this article as I was reminded of the potent Britishness of this book in language, setting, custom and plot. Whereas some horror stories are a bit more transferable, this one is as British as Let the Right One In is Scandinavian; as The Elementals is Southern American Gothic. 

A couple of things struck me this time around: one, there's a lot of focus on what Arthur is feeling and thinking, internally. It is a first person narrative, after all, but it's like - a scary thing happens, and it doesn't last for more than a moment, and then we are treated to like five pages of how Arthur feels about it all. Somehow - I'm not quite sure how - this really ratchets up the tension, especially considering that the WIB seems determined to make him feel her pain and grief. Anyway, his psychic turmoil is relatable. Two - this is a really, really simple plot. The awesome movie adaptations add this or that to their respective narrative arcs but I loved how basic things are in the book. There's him, and there's her.

I look forward to revisiting this again next spooky season - it's such a quick read, and it really does scratch the itch for a classic ghost story.

The Woman in Black on: Amazon | Bookshop.org | Goodreads | StoryGraph

Review: Lost in the Dark and Other Excursions

5+ stars. Finally! I hit a bit of a reading slump this Fall, so I turned to a beloved author hoping it would pull me out - and it did, 100%. This was dynamite, fantastic, satisfying, compelling, spooky, creative, disturbing, wonderful... There are many, many reasons why I love horror in all its forms, and reading this book was like soaking in a bath of all of them.

I don't always do a deep dive into short story collections but I cannot help myself here - Langan sets down in front of us a gorgeous, multi-course meal, so there's a lot to taste, chew on, and explore. Let's get into it:

Madame Painte 
Very cute, a little cheesy, and a little meta; an excellent opener and a perfect preview of what's to come in the book.

Lost in the Dark
BANGER. I would love this story expanded into a full epistolary novel. Vivid and full of unexpected details - plus, I'm a huge, huge super fan of found footage, so this was right up my alley. I didn't even mind the epistolary discrepancies (use of parentheticals in dialogue = pet peeve) or the many (many) narrative layers.

My Father, Dr. Frankenstein
Immediately wanted to read this one again. Brilliant. Made me smile - literally, as soon as I got to the last sentence I was chuckling.

A Song Only Partially Heard
A quaint monster vignette.

The Deep Sea Swell
A terrifying nightmare, full of the ocean/water imagery Langan is known for. Immediately wanted to read this one again as well.

Haak
WTF in the absolute best way. A masterclass in how to unfold a familiar story one singular note at a time until the reader recognizes the song. And then notices that it's a remix. And that there's an incredible beat drop. There's a touch of Ballingrud in this one.

Breakwater
Team Louise. 

Errata
Another weaker entry, but very amusing.

Natalya, Queen of the Hungry Dogs
Memorable, ooey gooey, and devastating.

Oscar Returns from the Dead, Prophesizing
A weaker entry but very entertaining. This one has a super dark and brutal ending... sneaks up on you.

Alice's Rebellion
Clever and cathartic.

Snakebit, Or Why I (Continue to) Love Horror
This is an academic essay as much as a narrative story, which I loved. I think folks who love horror, or are part of the genre in any way, are often very self-reflective and interested in the why of it all... Langan taps into that very effectively here. This is horror for horror nerds.

Clapping Teeth and Driving Beats
An adorable conclusion.

And finally he includes a set of spectacular story notes that explain a bit about each tale’s origin and inspirations. 

There's so much good stuff woven throughout: a lot related to water, nature, and the ocean, which we already know is a personal favorite of Langan's. There's also much to do with storytelling - its power, frankly. Its many shapes and sizes and its impact on the teller and the listener. He utilizes framing quite a bit but it never feels stale. He plays around with form, tone, and flavor enough to present a true variety of stories - I truly couldn't wait to finish one and start another. 

I revisited my review of The Fisherman - by the way, there’s a print of the painting from the cover of that book on my bedroom wall - and was reminded that I really wanted to discuss that one after finishing, too. Langan just brings something out of me - true excitement for the genre, curiosity, a vested interest in his work and the work and what comes next. He is a genius writer, from big ideas to the endearing characters to the smallest word choice.

If you are even a casual fan of horror, this belongs on your shelf. It opens so many doors and will take you on so many journeys. I can’t wait to read it again.

Lost in the Dark and Other Excursions on: Amazon | Bookshop.org | Goodreads | StoryGraph

Review: The Elementals

5 stars. WHAT was THAT! I have so many questions and theories and ideas - but ultimately I can't help but just call this book fun at the end of the day. Spooky, Southern, darkly funny and atmospheric - there's a reason this is considered one of the great classics of the 80s. It delivers and then some. 

The book follows two families joined by marriage - the McCoys and the Savages - after a familial loss as they travel to their isolated vacation properties deep in Alabama. The property consists of three houses, the third of which has been swallowed by a sand dune on the beach. But there appears to be something in the sand, something present in the third house - something hellbent on bringing darkness and destruction to the family - as has happened before and will happen again.

So - the things to know before diving in. This is a book reflective of its time, and there are many racist elements and tropes in the dialogue and characterizations of certain players. The pacing is odd and the narrative developments are clumsy and strange. I cannot emphasize enough how bizarre this book is. But I think what McDowell really nails - and what readers appreciate - is the depiction of the South - both its geographic features and also its nasty inhabitants. It absolutely reeks of Flannery O'Connor's casually vicious Southern personalities.

Through this lens one could definitely identify plenty of metaphors, and I've loved considering a few proposed by other reviewers: sand = blood, dead babies = family secrets, the house = ignored family history or unresolved trauma. McDowell intentionally includes very little exposition about the supernatural entities themselves, so we don't know much about their motivations or capabilities. Only what they look like, sometimes, and that's plenty to leave you scared. They are monstrous and truly grotesque.

I am curious about the debate around Luker. I thought his homosexuality was super obvious from the beginning - the clues only add up throughout the story. Again, this could tie into the theme of family secrets in the South (see also the family patriarch's corrupt, adulterous ways), which I do think enriches what could have been a simpler, more straightforward haunted house story. 

A couple of details I am not over, in a good way: the baby's jewelry, India's photographs, and the face in the window.

Weird, but I highly recommend.

The Elementals on: Amazon | Bookshop.org | Goodreads | StoryGraph

Review: The Diamond in the Window

5 stars. This book captivated me when I was younger - both my sister and I inherited it as a particular favorite of our mother’s. A family mystery, dream clues, an attic bedroom tucked away? We re-read it many times. We were also read other books in Jane Langton's repertoire (I can practically hear my dad's voice...) and enjoyed them all immensely. So I opened this with intense curiosity, hoping it would hold up. And it was... a fascinating experience.

Eleanor and Edward live in a very special house in Concord with their Aunt Lily and Uncle Freddy. They live a peaceful if somewhat sad family life, as several relatives are missing - having disappeared under mysterious circumstances years ago. When two very unpleasant townspeople threaten to repossess the house due to taxes owed, the children embark on a vivid, fantastic, dangerous treasure hunt to find their family and save their house.

From a writing perspective, this book is pretty much perfect. The descriptions are imaginative and colorful and captivating, the pacing is great for kids, and the way E&E's real-life experiences informed the dream games was honestly really fun. There are some important lessons embedded maybe not so subtly around selflessness, sacrifice, identity, knowledge, and choices - I stand by them. 

But I don't love that Eleanor's mirror path led her to motherhood, and Edward's reflected him as President. There were some odd religious overtones (or maybe undertones?)… just some intense/weird religious imagery that confused me... but honestly didn't phase me for a second as a kid. That stuff went right over my head - I never once connected it to religion in any way. So much for being “exposed” to dangerous concepts... I guess I was too dumb to be "corrupted."

So, yes, halfway through I was feeling 4 stars. But the ending wraps things up so beautifully - so, so beautifully - I can’t help but give it 5. It's a wonderful, transporting, adventure story. There are some dark and spooky moments which only add to the thrill. And these characters - you cannot help but love them, deeply. Uncle Freddy forever.

The Diamond in the Window on: Amazon | Bookshop.org | Goodreads | StoryGraph

Review: The Egypt Game

5 stars. Could not have enjoyed this more - it had me staying up late, "one more chapter" and all that! I wonder if this book kickstarted my Egypt phase, back in the day? Regardless, I highly, highly recommend this for readers of all ages - it's a timeless classic, an important story, and a ridiculously fun, good time. I cried at the end (pregnant). 

When young April Hall moves to town, she quickly befriends Melanie Ross, discovering a mutual love for all things Ancient Egypt. Together with Melanie's younger brother Marshall they invent The Egypt Game, adopting an old storage shed behind a junk shop for their rituals and ceremonies. But as the Game grows, strange things happen, and the players start to wonder if they've conjured the magic of Ancient Egypt after all...

I actually cannot believe how well-written and clever this is. The author really channels - successfully - the quirks and voices of the kids, infusing some really important and powerful lessons into the narrative. The representation - for a book published in 1967 - is incredible, and I nearly dropped the book when I realized there's a MURDER SUBPLOT?! What do you mean? Could this book be any further up my alley?

There's plenty for adults. It's a throwback to the joy of immersive, imaginative play, and there are clever references to the tensions of its time: the Civil Rights movement, for example. I don't think it's an accident that the murderer turned out to be a white ginger from a well-respected family. It's funny, and insightful without knocking you over the head, and don't even get me started on Mr. Ross calling April "the cruelest month...." 

I loved this book as a kid, and I love it now. There's so much to read, out there, but let this be a sign: revisit the good ones, occasionally. It's very rewarding.

The Egypt Game on: Amazon | Bookshop.org | Goodreads | StoryGraph

Review: Experimental Film

5 stars. Overjoyed to report that my thirst for reading is back after a short break due to first trimester illness and blues (this happened last time too). I missed my Kindle, I missed the escape, and I missed the bone deep satisfaction earned from an immersive story. But I just couldn't read. I wasn't sure if I'd have to give up on this book, honestly, because certain things get unfortunately associated with nausea when you're pregnant, but I was really determined with this one - I sensed something in it, and persevered - I'm so glad I did.

Because it ended up saving me during a particularly difficult week - chasing around a toddler on a beach trip - like, truly engulfing me after the meltdowns and the overstimulation and the stressful World Cup games took their toll. I was thrilled to read even a few pages here and there, stolen in between tantrums and during naps. I absolutely adored Lois' voice and I really rooted for her. She's an incredibly strong and real-feeling protagonist.

I'm getting ahead of myself. Experimental Film is about an out-of-work film critic/former film professor who stumbles upon the vivid work of one of Canada's original filmmakers, a woman who, after the disappearance of her son, also disappears under mysterious circumstances. Lois receives a grant to investigate, but her research leads her down a strange and apparently dangerous path for her family. 

I have seen other reviews criticize this book for a couple of things: for being derivative of certain works - American Gods is one, Night Film is another; for the infodump/detailed exposition about the Canadian film industry; for the slow first half. And I get it, I really do. But I happened to love both AG and NF, and recognized the info dumping as an intentional piece of Lois' characterization. I would argue that this book is in fact large part character study, which makes it even crazier and more interesting when Lois has to channel both her best and worst instincts during the final climax. 

It's not a book for everyone. But I absolutely loved the central mystery here, as well as the primary antagonist, and the way everything unfolded. I appreciated Simon's strength and support as a partner. I understood Lois' struggles as a parent of a child on the spectrum. I gobbled up the descriptions of the films, the threads of dark mythology and folk horror, and the spooky moments. The historical lore is truly disturbing here and I kind of wanted more. 

Idk. This one felt really, really special. I feel like I have so much more to say, but I want to say it to someone who's read it - there's a lot to discuss. And while we’re listing things we want, an illustrated and/or annotated version would be very welcome, thanks very much :)

Experimental Film on: Amazon | Bookshop.org | Goodreads | StoryGraph

Review: The Wrath of Angels (Charlie Parker #11

5 stars. Oh hell yeah, Connolly crushed this. We got a super dark thriller, we got the return of an epic villain, we got some grade A banter with Angel and Louis, we got a glimpse of Colonial horror (finally! the series is set in New England, after all!) and, best of all, we got some answers. Absolutely loved it.

Our poor dear detective Charlie Parker is hired by two acquaintances whose fathers have recently passed away - but not before sharing the details of a secret discovery made years before: the crashsite of a plane, deep in the woods, and with it, money - a lot of money, and a list of names. Parker immediately realizes the importance of this list, and enlists the help of his old friends to ensure he finds it before it falls into the wrong, evil hands.

John Connolly is building a truly impressive mythology here - one that is quite dark and scary. The pieces are falling into place and I'm so pleased to report that even 10+ books later my memory hasn't failed me in any major ways. I'm not quite sure how to explain this, but it feels like the author really, really tried with this one - with the plotting, the pacing, and the way the characters orbited each other. His efforts paid off.

I particularly enjoyed the inclusion of local folklore, here, and the way it intersected with the main plot. It lended a fresh, spooky edge to the setting as well as a very satisfying demise of a certain character. Sometimes Connolly's deep dives into character or place can be tedious; here it was fascinating and fun. 

Look - these books are a bit ridiculous, okay? A list of names - really? A sophisticated shadow organization with unlimited resources and they rely on hard copies? But I truly didn't mind. I loved that the list created this sort of dark treasure hunt vibe - a set-up for a terrific reveal.

I am excited to keep the series going. This should really be a TV series.

The Wrath of Angels on: Amazon | Bookshop.org | Goodreads | StoryGraph

Review: The Great Ghost Rescue

5 stars. 1 for being delightfully dark and spooky, which spoke to me as a kid (I can see so vividly my horror-loving origins); 1 for its heartfelt message against displacing populations who are different from your own - and forgiveness; 1 for its atmospheric setting; 1 for its tight pacing and writing; and 1 for the bravery of its two unlikely heroes: Rick and Humphrey the Horrible. 

Ghosts across Britain are facing a crisis. Uprooted by technology, modern society, industry, and capitalism - and all the buildings and highways that come with - these creatures are torn from their peaceful haunts and essentially made homeless. One family, forced by their Scottish ancestral home, has the good fortune to encounter a young boy who wants to help. Together, they hatch a plan to create a safe place for wandering souls: a sanctuary. Shenanigans ensue. 

Eva Ibbottson is one of the greats - I hate that she was marketed to "fans of J.K. Rowling" when I was a kid (which you can still find on the covers). To me, she is better. Sure, she has a sort of similar quirky sense of dark humor and whimsy when it comes to the supernatural (if you squint your eyes), and I guess they're both... British, but she's just simply a much better writer - from the big picture premise down to the sentence level. 

It holds up. Very funny, very witty, and very spooky. I have this weird anxiety around somehow "forcing" my kids to consume the media I enjoyed as a kid (dooming them to a torturously "uncool" existence, out of the loop on all current playground obsessions), but these are classics, right?! They aren't even problematic, right?! Being spooky is genetic, right?! It's actually my duty to give her a well-rounded, foundational education, right?!

The Great Ghost Rescue on: Amazon | Bookshop.org | Goodreads | StoryGraph

Review: Shirley Jackson: A Rather Haunted Life

10 stars. I highly, highly recommend this compelling and detailed biography. For those curious about Shirley Jackson's life, this book offers two golden outcomes: it will satisfy your curiosity and elevate your reading experience of her works. It's the perfect blend of gossipy and academic; it's possibly the most successful, engrossing biography I've ever read and will make the Kelly Choice Awards, no question.

Organized chronologically, A Rather Haunted Life begins with Jackson's family background early upbringing, eventually settling into a rhythm where each chapter dives into a major work - notes on its development, a summary, some excellent analysis, and the public reaction - with the life stuff woven in. The author, Ruth Franklin, incorporates well-placed pictures, footnotes, excerpts, and quotes, painting what rings to me as a fair and accurate portrait of one of the most brilliant American minds.

There are major themes: Jackson's fraught relationship with her mother, for example, her messy marriage, and the impossible push and pull Jackson felt between her occupation and her role as housewife and mother herself. These are prominent themes in the biography and also themes in Jackson's work. But Franklin never neglects the little details - the minor tidbits - that make Jackson so effective and admirable:

"In “Notes for a Young Writer,” a lecture on writing fiction composed as advice to her daughter Sarah, Jackson would relish the “grotesque effect” of the “absolutely wrong word”: “ ‘I will always love you,’ he giggled.”"

I should admit that I am the perfect audience for this sort of thing: a wannabe student of the horror genre and a Shirley Jackson superfan. Every page was interesting to me. I didn't want it to end. I read and re-read passages, returned and referenced many times (the chapter on her encounter with Dylan Thomas was especially fascinating, as were the descriptions of Bennington College, one of the most unique higher institutions in America). 

Some readers may feel that Franklin expects a bit too much. My own gaps in knowledge around Marxism and Communism and the American political landscape pre-WWII were super apparent. And I'm embarrassed to say that I didn't recognize many of the author names - popular contemporaries of Jackson and Hyman. That's okay - more to learn. It didn't impact my understanding or takeaways about the book's subject.

Speaking of takeaways, a big personal one for me involves parallels. Franklin points out the way McCarthyism echoes the Salem Witch Trials, a topic on which Shirley Jackson published a book. Jackson notes these familiarities between past and present below - and it's impossible to not continue the pattern and draw lines connecting the past, Shirley's present, and our present today.

"But if “fashions in fear change,” people do not. The intelligent are in the minority, their measured voices in constant danger of being drowned out by the din of the mob. “We are not more tolerant or more valiant than the people of Salem, and we are just as willing to do battle with an imaginary enemy,” she wrote resignedly. “The people of Salem hanged and tortured their neighbors from a deep conviction that they were right to do so. Some of our own deepest convictions may be as false. We might say that we have far more to be afraid of today than the people of Salem ever dreamed of, but that would not really be true. We have exactly the same thing to be afraid of—the demon in men’s minds which prompts hatred and anger and fear, an irrational demon which shows a different face to every generation, but never gives up in his fight to win over the world.”"

I'm so used to hearing the word "unprecedented," I forgot that political bullshit has existed since the beginning. To be reminded so eloquently is somehow both distressing and comforting at the same time.

The idea that so much is apparently and unfortunately universal across time and space manifests in other, more personal ways. I was really struck by the sense of kinship I felt with someone who lived decades ago, in a different world. The struggles a young Shirley experienced in adolescence and early adulthood were familiar - classic tropes, really: feeling like an odd or ugly outsider, feeling unwanted, feeling socially/romantically undesirable and awkward/ungainly. That familiarity stayed with me through her anxieties of raising children in a chaotic world. The undeniable pull Shirley felt to leave - to drop everything, to untether herself, to just exist, almost noncorporeal, even at the cost of so much - is understandable, and relatable. 

One more thing: many words are included on the various questions and interpretations around the meaning of The Lottery - which was a true cultural moment. But honestly (and this in my mind is reinforced by her grumbling about it), it seems to me that Jackson simply baked a dough made of her astute perceptive nature, her dark humor, her penchant towards sarcasm and exaggeration and irony, plus her knowledge of ritual, and out came the story. I’d believe that sooner than I’d believe in some sort of preachy social commentary or agenda, though some of that was probably baked in naturally.

A Rather Haunted Life is so many things: a portrait of a person, and a marriage; a literary analysis; a snapshot of a specific moment in American history; a glimpse into the world of the generation that raised my parents; a study of repressed rage. And now it's also my entire personality. 

Shirley Jackson: A Rather Haunted Life on: Amazon | Bookshop.org | Goodreads | StoryGraph